What happens to your SEO when you redesign your website?

—

A new website is exciting. A new design, better content, a faster build. What nobody mentions in the kick-off meeting is that a redesign is also the most common way for a business to lose its Google traffic overnight.

It doesn't have to happen. When it does, it is almost never because the new site is worse. It's because the old pages, the ones Google and your customers already know about, stopped being where they were. This post explains why, what to do about it, and what to ask any agency (including us) before you commit.

The short version

  • Search engines rank addresses, not websites. If a page's URL changes and nothing points the old one to the new one, the ranking and the visitors it brought are lost.
  • The fix is a redirect map: a list of every old URL and where it should send people now. It needs to be made before launch, not after the traffic drops.
  • Some dip is normal. A cliff isn't. A well-handled redesign should see rankings wobble and recover, not disappear.
  • Ask to see the map. If an agency can't show you how they will handle old URLs, they probably haven't planned to.

Why URLs matter more than the design

Every page on your site has an address, for example yoursite.com/services/web-design. Google has spent years learning what that address is about, who links to it, and how people behave when they land there. That history is attached to the address, not to the way the page looks.

When you redesign, it's very common for addresses to change. A different CMS builds them differently. A tidier structure renames /our-services/ to /services/. A product range is reorganised. Each of those is sensible on its own, and each one makes the old address stop working.

When someone visits an address that no longer exists, they get a "page not found" error. Google gets the same error, and over the following weeks it drops that page from its results. The links other sites have given you stop counting. A returning customer clicking an old bookmark or an email link reaches a dead end.

What a redirect map is

A redirect tells a browser, and Google, "this page has moved, go here instead". The kind we use is called a 301, which means permanently moved. It carries most of the page's search history across to the new address, and people end up where they wanted to be without noticing anything happened.

A redirect map is simply the full list: old address on the left, new address on the right. It sounds simple, and for a 10-page site it is. For a site with hundreds of pages, news articles, product pages and years of old content, it is a proper piece of work, and the quality of it is one of the clearest differences between a careful agency and a careless one.

What we do before launch

This is our process on a redesign or a move to a new platform:

  1. Crawl the old site. We use a crawling tool to collect every address on the current site, the same way a search engine would, so we aren't relying on someone's memory of what exists. On a recent redesign we found over 200 old addresses.
  2. Check what matters. Not every address deserves a redirect. We look at which pages have search traffic, which have links from other sites, and which are in your own navigation and emails. These are the ones we protect first. Old test pages, duplicate addresses and obsolete junk can be left to disappear.
  3. Build the new site's structure and match old to new. Many pages have an obvious twin on the new site. Others need a decision: has this page been merged into another, or genuinely retired?
  4. Write the map. On a recent redesign this came to 23 redirect rules: 17 one-to-one matches and six pattern rules that handle whole groups of pages at once, for example everything that used to live in one section now living in another.
  5. Test it before the site goes live, and again after. We re-check every old address to confirm it lands on the right page, in one step, with no errors and no loops.
  6. Watch Google afterwards. In the weeks after launch we monitor Google Search Console for errors and for pages dropping out, and fix anything we missed.

(Our developers have written up the technical side, including the scripts we use, in Bulk redirect mapping with Retour from a crawl.)

Other things that go wrong in a redesign

Redirects are the big one, but they're not the only way to lose traffic:

  • Page titles and headings get rewritten without anyone checking what was ranking for what. A page that ranked for "wedding venue Cumbria" gets a new title about "celebrations" and quietly stops ranking.
  • Content gets cut because it "feels too long", including the pages that were quietly doing the work.
  • The new site is blocked from Google. Development sites are usually hidden from search engines on purpose. If that setting isn't switched off at launch, the new site stays invisible. It's a classic mistake, and it's avoidable with a launch checklist.
  • Tracking breaks. If analytics or form tracking isn't carried across, you can't tell what's happening, which makes every other problem harder to spot.
  • The new site is slower. A heavier design can undo the gains from everything else.

How long until things settle?

Expect some movement. When Google finds a redirect it has to re-crawl the old address, follow it, and update what it knows. This usually takes weeks rather than days, and sometimes a couple of months for larger sites.

Two things are worth knowing:

  • Keep the redirects in place for a long time. Google's own guidance is to keep them for at least a year. Removing them early because "the list is getting long" undoes the work.
  • A small dip is fine; a sustained drop is a signal. If traffic has fallen sharply and not started to recover after several weeks, something has been missed, and the redirect map is the first place to look.

Questions to ask any agency before you sign

  • Will you crawl our current site and give us the list of addresses before we agree the new structure?
  • Who is responsible for the redirect map, and can we see it before launch?
  • How do you decide which old pages to redirect and which to retire?
  • How will you check that every redirect works, and who checks it?
  • What do you monitor in the weeks after launch, and for how long?
  • Is the new site hidden from search engines while it is being built, and who switches that off at launch?

If the answers are vague, that tells you something.

Planning a redesign?

If you're thinking about a new website and don't want to lose what the current one has earned, talk to us before the design starts. That is the cheapest point at which to protect your rankings, and we'll give you a straight answer about what's at risk.